Love Island USA Season 3 was such a disappointment with low-quality romances and fleeting couples.
Find out where the cast members are now and why the fans were so let down. Love Island USA Season 3 launched in the summer of 2021 with high hopes, hunky singles, and a new venue in Hawaii. The fans were looking forward to an unforgettable season with hot romance, over-the-top drama, and likable contestants. But what they received in return was one of the worst seasons ever. Love Island USA Season 3 fell on so many levels—chemistry, reality, and even entertainment value. With a little time having gone by, fans are now wondering: where are the contestants now, and did anyone fall in love at all?
A Rocky Start in Paradise
The Season 3 setting of Love Island USA in a Hawaiian villa was a pleasant variation from the Las Vegas setup of Season 2. The lovely surroundings hinted at something tropical and celebratory. But ever since the first few days, viewers felt something was off. The atmosphere was staged. The Islanders did not worry more about connecting but clout.
In comparison to previous seasons, Love Island USA Season 3 had poorer opening couples. The dialogue was cringeworthy, and the majority of pairings were not chemistry-driven. Social media users were displeased, tagging the season as “boring” and “fake.” The magic of Season 1 or even the excitement of Season 2 was evidently missing this season.
The Winners: Korey and Olivia
The greatest surprise winner of Love Island USA Season 3 was the winning couple—Korey Gandy and Olivia Kaiser. Few fans predicted that they would reach the finals, let alone win the $100,000 prize. In fact, Korey and Olivia began dating near the end of the season, so the surprise was huge for most.
Olivia had been paired with certain Islanders prior to when she picked Korey. People believed their romance was the work of tactic, not love. Korey was well-known for his honesty and positivity, yet Olivia’s surprise interest in him made eyes raise. They winning proved there weren’t sufficient solid, honest couples in Season 3 of Love Island USA.
Korey and Olivia are not a couple anymore today. They broke up shortly after the show was over. Olivia returned to her makeup and beauty career, whereas Korey focused on modeling and fitness. Just like in many reality TV relationships, their romance did not stand the cameras.
Fan Favorites Who Left Too Soon
A few of Love Island USA Season 3’s contestants rose to fame despite failing to make it to the final. One such contestant was Cashay Proudfoot, who achieved popularity with her kind and sweet personality, getting a huge following. The most controversial story on the season revolved around her romantic involvement between Cinco and Trina.
Cashay’s emotional journey was easy to relate to for viewers. Her relationship with Cinco seemed real, but the back-and-forth show drama exhausted viewers over time. Cashay and Cinco attempted to make it work in real life after the show, but the couple broke up. Cashay continues to build her social media following and has a strong fan base.
Another well-known fan was Will Moncada, with whom Kyra Lizama was coupled. The two appeared to be on good terms while the show was on, but his fans wondered what his intentions were following his actions in Casa Amor. Everyone thought that Kyra deserved much better. Despite this, they made it to the final and remained together for a few months following the show. They have since parted ways.
Where Are They Now?
Let’s take a closer look at what some of the Islanders of Love Island USA Season 3 are up to these days:
Olivia Kaiser: Went back to beauty and makeup. Also featured on The Challenge reality show.
Korey Gandy: Was concentrated on fitness and world travel. Shares his journey on Instagram.
Cashay Proudfoot: Was trendy on social media. Still engaged in the entertainment industry.
Cinco Holland: Developed a strong following. Operates fitness programs and modeling services.
Kyra Lizama: Health and wellness professional. Keeps it low-key.
Will Moncada: Is a globe-trotter. Has been running a yoga and wellness brand.
It’s obvious that although some of the Love Island USA Season 3 cast members took the show as a stepping stone to stardom, not many of them found eternal love. This aspect contributed to the reality that this season was not real.
A Social Media Generation
One of the largest complaints regarding Love Island USA Season 3 was that most of the Islanders appeared to care more about getting followers than they did about love. Several of the Islanders had amassed significant social media followings prior to appearing on the show. Throughout the season, it was clear that clout and influencer aspirations were the priorities, not relationships.
The editing also didn’t work. So many of the episodes were slow, repetitive, and filled with too much drama. The audience craved real moments and character growth, but Love Island USA Season 3 gave them more fluff than substance.
Casa Amor Flop
Casa Amor is always the highlight of every Love Island season. It stresses relationships and comes with jaw-dropping surprises. But Love Island USA Season 3’s Casa Amor didn’t. The majority of the drama was predictable. There were hardly any significant shake-ups.
The most dramatic thing from Casa Amor was Will’s dodgy antics and how that affected Kyra. Aside from that, there were no meltdown moments. The twist was considered by fans to be subpar and executed poorly.
Missing Powerful Love Stories
Unlike previous seasons, Love Island USA Season 3 did not provide the audience with any true fairy tale romance. There were no Zac and Elizabeth (Season 1) or Justine and Caleb (Season 2) moments. The couples seemed mismatched and the relationships did not seem profound.
Even the winners, Olivia and Korey, lacked the solid foundation which viewers like to think about and root for. Their romance looked more like that of friends turned love interests rather than romance. The viewers watching Love Island look up to them to believe the romance stories. Unfortunately, Love Island USA Season 3 did not do this believing so justice.
Too Many Red Flags
The second most prominent recurring theme of Love Island USA Season 3 was red flags—poor communication, questionable loyalty, and only surface-level bonding. Players just switched partners randomly without real feelings. Discussions appeared staged or untrue. Fans reported that the show made them realize they were witnessing a production and not a quest for love.
Producers were also faulted for casting and editing. Certain of the most popular fan scenes were omitted, with gratuitous drama being shown repeatedly instead. The audience was thus disengaged from the show.
Legacy of Season 3
Flawed as it was, Love Island USA Season 3 still drew in viewers and started conversations. But its legacy is stained. It is generally regarded by most fans as the worst season so far. It is a lesson for subsequent seasons—impact, good casting, and chemistry do count.
Though some of the contestants became popular and well-known, the season did not produce a classic fan couple or love story. That is why all of them call it the most disappointing season.
A Glimpse at Redemption
Interestingly, a few of the former Islanders of Love Island USA Season 3 found their ways onto other reality television programs. Olivia appeared as a guest on The Challenge, while Cinco and Cashay appeared on Ex on the Beach. These guest appearances kept them in the limelight and revived their TV image.
But these glitches did not alter the overall impression of Love Island USA Season 3. The fans continue to anticipate future seasons in the hope that producers will learn from errors.
What Fans Want Next
Audiences are demanding more authentic connections, less influencers, and improved storylines. Audiences want to see people fall in love, not game. Upcoming seasons require improved editing, improved casting, and going back to the initial concept of Love Island: building love in a paradise.
5 FAQs About Love Island USA Season 3
1. Who is the winner of Love Island USA Season 3?
Korey Gandy and Olivia Kaiser were the winners of Love Island USA Season 3, though the majority of the fans were shocked by the outcome.
2. Are there any of the couples from Love Island USA Season 3 still together?
No, there are no couples from Love Island USA Season 3 still together after the finale.
3. Why are fans disappointed with Love Island USA Season 3?
Most fans considered Love Island USA Season 3 to have minimal authentic romance, chemistry, and decent drama. The season was not authentic and felt staged compared to previous seasons.
4. What became of Cashay and Cinco after the show?
Cashay and Cinco attempted to date following the show but eventually broke up. Both have active social media presence and continued on with additional reality TV career routes.
5. Was Love Island USA Season 3 a success?
Even if it got positive ratings, Love Island USA Season 3 is overall considered to be a failure since it never had any notable couples and it was not very deep.
Conclusion
In short, Love Island USA Season 3 teased fans with a summer of love and delivered little to none. Although some of the cast members gained temporary popularity and audience support, the season will largely be remembered by what it was missing—true love stories. With the necessary changes, future seasons can still regain the magic fans crave. Still, until then, Love Island USA Season 3 is one such letdown in the franchise’s history.
Amber Saif